MARYLAND SCHOOL FOR THE DEAF
BOARD OF TRUSTEES
Meeting Minutes
May 30, 2003
Frederick Campus


MEMBERS PRESENT: David S. Birnbaum; Donald R. Eichelberger; H. Mitchell Goldberg; Harvey Goodstein, Ph.D.; Sandra N. Harriman; Joseph J. Innes, Ph.D.; Alan L. Marcus, Ph.D.; Anjali Desai-Margolin; Edgar B. Palmer; Charles E. Poyer, Jr.; Barbara Raimondo; David A. Severn, Esq.; Samuel M Sonnenstrahl; Carol Stevens.

MEMBERS ABSENT: Ann H.B. Brockenborough, Ed.D.; John Ertel, Ph.D.; Irajean W. Harper; Laurie Yaffe-Shevitz.

ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL: Lori P. Hopkins

INTERPRETERS: Roberta Quinn; Brenda Kelly-Frey.

President Lewis called the meeting to order at 9:05 a.m.. Roll call was called by passing the roll call sheet.

Introductions were made of all the attending Board members including the two new members who were attending their first Board of Trustees quarterly meeting.

MOTION made to approve the Agenda – SECONDED – PASSED

MOTION made to approve the Minutes of the November 2002 minutes with a correction on the spelling of the Consultant’s name – SECONDED – PASSED. These minutes can now be posted on the MSD website.

MOTION made to approve the Executive Committee Meeting Minutes with a correction on the spelling of the Chairman’s name – SECONDED – PASSED. These minutes are not posted on the website but may be available upon request. It was decided that information on how to obtain copies of these minutes will be posted on the MSD website in the future so the public will be aware of the proper procedure to acquire copies of these documents.

President’s Report:
President Lewis explained that his term as President of the BOT will end today. He told the members that it has been a pleasure working with the Board and Mr. Tucker all these years. A discussion was held regarding the membership changes that will take place for the BOT in 2004.

Dr. Lewis informed the Board members that he and Vice President Palmer had met with Mr. Al Couthen, a speaker at the March Open Forum. Mr. Couthen’s survey was discussed and questions were asked regarding information on the MSD website. Mr. Couthen plans on speaking during the Open Forum today.

Vice President’s Report:
No Report

Secretary’s Report:
No Report

Treasurer’s Report:
Mr. Eichelberger gave the BOT the latest information on funds in the petty cash account, the Ferris Baker Watts Trustee account and the Reserved Primary Fund. The Treasurer informed the BOT that $12,000.00 had been taken from that fund to pay for computers for the school and to pay the consultant fees.
Mr. Eichelberger explained that he has been the liaison to the MSD Foundation for several years and that the Foundation is trying some new direction for fund raising. Any support the BOT members can give the Foundation is greatly appreciated. It was discussed that not all BOT members received the Foundation’s last solicitation letter. The mailing list will be discussed with the Foundation.

At 9:27 A.M. a MOTION was made to go into closed session for the purpose of discussing student issues. SECONDED – PASSED 14 – 0. See Attached.

PRESENT: David S. Birnbaum; Donald R. Eichelberger; H. Mitchell Goldberg; Harvey Goodstein, Ph.D.; Sandra N. Harriman; Joseph J. Innes, Ph.D.; Alan L. Marcus, Ph.D.; Anjali Desai-Margolin; Edgar B. Palmer; Charles E. Poyer, Jr.; Barbara Raimondo; David A. Severn, Esq.; Samuel M Sonnenstrahl; Carol Stevens.

ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL: Lori P. Hopkins

INTERPRETERS: Roberta Quinn; Brenda Kelly-Frey.

At 11:04 A.M. a MOTION was made to return to open session. SECONDED – PASSED 14-0.

PRESENT: David S. Birnbaum; Donald R. Eichelberger; H. Mitchell Goldberg; Harvey Goodstein, Ph.D.; Sandra N. Harriman; Joseph J. Innes, Ph.D.; Alan L. Marcus, Ph.D.; Anjali Desai-Margolin; Edgar B. Palmer; Charles E. Poyer, Jr.; Barbara Raimondo; David A. Severn, Esq.; Samuel M Sonnenstrahl; Carol Stevens.

ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL: Lori P. Hopkins

INTERPRETERS: Roberta Quinn; Brenda Kelly-Frey.

Superintendent’s Report:
The Superintendent told the BOT that this has been a challenging year. It started with the sniper situation in the fall, then the many snow storms disrupted normal operations at the school and then the Iraq war distracted many of the students and staff.
*19 Seniors will graduate from MSD on June 7, 2003. Mr. Lindsay Dunn will be the graduation speaker.
*The budget for the coming year has only been slightly touched so far.
The language in the Budget Reconciliation Financial Act gave the General Assembly the power to cut “Administrative Costs” at the school. This resulted in a loss of $11,000.00 from our proposed budget. While the Governor can make the cuts necessary to make the State Budget work, the Department of Budget and Management says that the school is not on the table currently for more cuts. They can not promise us however, what the future holds.
*No Child Left Behind (NCLB) – A discussion was held regarding the new teacher certification requirements under “NCLB”. We are currently working on getting the teachers certified to meet the requirements. We are encouraging the teachers in our secondary program to get their certification this summer. Teachers in the Middle School and High School programs who teach the core content areas (math, language, science etc.) will have to be “Highly Qualified” by the 2005-2006 school year.

Education Committee:
Report presented after lunch.

Fiscal Matters/Facilities Management Committee:
No Report.

Personnel Committee:
The BOT members were informed that Ms. Eva Staubitz, Director of Personnel, would present the recommended changes in the Staff Handbook to the BOT after lunch.
The Personnel Committee was asked to start working on the Superintendent’s evaluation and the goals for the next year.

Trusteeship Committee:
The Committee met with the two new BOT members at 8:00 a.m. today.

Strategic Planning Committee:
The committee met last spring with Mr. Stanley C. Baker. The upcoming Middle States Accreditation (MSA) process was the main topic of discussion. The school will be visited by the MSA team in November of 2004. The committee is working with Mr. Baker to see how the BOT best can assist with the accreditation process. They are also working on plans for the BOT for the future.
Any BOT member interested in working on this committee should contact Barbara Raimondo.

President Lewis explained that three former BOT members would be honored for their service to the Board at lunchtime. The Board would also honor one current member who is retiring and moving out of state this summer.

At 12:59 P.M. President Lewis explained to the BOT members and members of the community present the procedure used for Open Forum. The first speaker was Mr. Al Couthen. Mr. Couthen told the members of the BOT that he sent a survey to former employees and former parents. He handed out the results of the survey to the members of the Board.

The second speaker – Ms. Marsha Flowers – Thanked several members of the community for their dedication to MSD. Among those thanked were Board member Harvey Goodstein, FC Principal Stanley C. Baker, Dr. William Sherman – school psychologist who is retiring after 23 years of service to the school and Mr. James Tucker – Superintendent of the school.

Ms. Shirlene Tharpe was the third speaker to present to the BOT. A parent of three children at MSD, she explained that she has requested a transfer for her son so she can have all three children at the Frederick Campus. Her request was denied due to the fact that she is not in the Frederick geographic district for elementary children but explained that the transportation issue is causing hardship to the family.

The fourth speaker was Ms. Terri Boyer. Ms. Boyer explained to the Board that in her years here at the school both as Executive Associate to the Superintendent and as the Assistant Director of Personnel for MSD, her experience has been that the decisions made by the Superintendent have always been made with the best interest of the children in mind and the decisions were made after receiving input from the management team and the school attorney.

Open Forum ended at 1:50 P.M.

The Board reviewed the district policy in the handbook. There was a discussion of why the policy was established and how the district lines were drawn. It was explained that transfer requests can be submitted annually.

Old Business:
Extended School Year Services (ESY) – The BOT discussed what ESY is and how it has worked in years past. The arrangement made between MSD and the Maryland Counties was explained. Mr. Tucker explained that the Maryland Department of Education would like MSD to assume full responsibility for educating our children year round but this will require extra money for MSD and for the local school systems (LSS) which is not in the ’04 budget. This program can be added to the ’05 budget. Discussions between MSD, MSDE and the LSS are still taking place on the subject.

Master Plan – The hearing for the 15 year Master Plan has been scheduled for Monday July 14, 2003. Lori Hopkins shared with the BOT that she believed the recommendation presented at the last BOT meeting to delete the Elementary Residential Cottage from the Master Plan was a wise one. A MOTION was made to remove the Elementary Cottage from the Master Plan – SECONDED – APPROVED.

Shockley House – Mr. Tucker explained to the BOT that the Grand Opening of the Shockley House located on the corner of Clarke Place and South Carol Street is being targeted for late September. The request for the name change now has to go before the Board of Public Works.

New Business:
Elections: Dr. Marcus, Chairman of the Personnel Committee thanked those members who have served the Board and the school in leadership positions for the past two years – President Jeffrey Lewis, Vice President Bernie Palmer, Secretary Ann Brockenborough and Treasurer Don Eichelberger.
MOTION was made to open nominations for officer positions and Executive Committee positions – SECONDED – PASSED.
Nominations for BOT officers by acclimation:
President Barbara Raimondo
Vice President Edgar B. Palmer
Secretary Anjali Desai-Margolin
Treasurer H. Mitchell Goldberg
Nominations for Executive Committee members at large:
Samuel M Sonnenstrahl
Carol Stevens
Charles E. Poyer, Jr.
MOTION made to accept the nominations and elect the nominated members – SECONDED – PASSED.

It was announced that the Executive Committee would meet briefly after the BOT meeting to select the Chairman and Secretary of the committee.

A MOTION was made to refer the approval of the Parent/Student handbook changes to the Executive Committee – SECONDED – PASSED.

The changes to the Personnel Handbook were reviewed by Ms. Eva Staubitz and Ms. Terri Boyer of the Personnel Department. A question was asked regarding the people in charge during a crisis. It was explained that memos were distributed to staff and parents with that information.

A MOTION was made to accept the recommended changes to the Staff Handbook as presented – SECONDED – PASSED.

A MOTION was made that the recommended out of State tuition be accepted as listed in the handout – SECONDED – PASSED.

Newly elected President Raimondo informed the BOT that they are in need of two members who could join the accreditation team. One member would serve on the Frederick Campus sub group and the second would serve on the Columbia Campus sub group. These groups will meet monthly starting this summer and last through November of 2004.
A MOTION was made that Barbara Raimondo and Carol Stevens represent the BOT for on the MSA Committee – SECONDED – PASSED.
Committee Membership was posted by Dr. Marcus.
Student Life Committee – Edgar B. Palmer, Chairman; David S. Birnbaum; Carol Stevens; Samuel M Sonnenstrahl
Personnel Committee- Alan Marcus, Ph.D., Chairman; David S. Birnbaum; Anjali Desai-Margolin; David Severn, Esquire.
Education Committee – Joseph J. Innes Ph.D., Chairman; Jeffrey W. Lewis, Ph.D.; Barbara Raimondo
Fiscal Matters/ Facilities Management Committee - H. Mitchell Goldberg, Chairman; John Ertel, Ph.D.; Ann H. B. Brockenborough, Ed.D.
Trusteeship Committee – Sandra Harriman, Chairman; Charles E. Poyer, Jr.; Laurie Yaffe-Shevitz

The Board of Trustees meeting dates for the 2003/2004 school year are:
Thursday August 28, 2003 Columbia Campus
Friday November 21, 2003 Frederick Campus
Friday February 27, 2004 Columbia Campus
Friday May 21, 2004 Frederick Campus

A MOTION was made to reimburse the Maryland School for the Deaf for the gifts that were purchased for the departing BOT members – SECONDED – PASSED.

Dr. Richard Steffan, Jr., Deputy Superintendent/Principal of the Columbia Campus presented information on the students at Columbia. The BOT members were informed that the Columbia enrollment is on the rise. There has also been a marked increase in enrollment from children with additional disabilities The primary service area for the Columbia Campus is Baltimore County, Baltimore City, Howard County and Prince Georges County.
Dr. Steffan shared with the Board that Family Education enrollment has decreased since the year 2000. The school is not getting as many referrals from the hospitals in Baltimore as it used to receive. Teachers in this department travel into the community to work with families of deaf children and to teach sign language to the hearing parents of these students. The goal is to help open the lines of communication between the parents and the children.

Mr. Stanley C. Baker, Assistant Superintendent/Principal of the Frederick Campus gave a presentation on students in Frederick. Mr. Paul Rittenhour, MSD computer programmer, assisted with the presentation. Mr. Baker shared that new testing mandates are impacting achievement statistics. Slides showing the reading and math scores were presented. Board members were reminded that the small number of students we have eligible to take these tests impact the scores which indicate our success rate as a school. These new tests are part of the NCLB program but there are still issues that need to be worked out such as cultural bias that is still present in many of the tests.

The meeting adjourned at 4:06 P.M.

Respectfully Submitted,


Anjali Desai-Margolin
Secretary